All matches
Championship · 2022/2023
Reading 1-1 Luton
Home

Match Report

Reading
A Carroll (51)
Luton
C Morris (80)
Reading fans experienced the full range of emotional turmoil in the space of four dramatic second half minutes, courtesy of Andy Carroll. With so much at stake for both teams (although probably more for Reading) it was a cagey sort of game from the outset, but just five minutes after the interval the game exploded into life.

Femi Azeez whipped in a corner to the near post where Carroll, with typically perfect timing powerfully headed Reading into the lead. The home crowd erupted with a mixture of joy and relief as survival suddenly became a more realistic prospect. Four minutes later, another corner to Reading was again diverted in to the net by Andy Carroll. With Reading fans now in a state of euphoria, referee Tim Robinson was being pursued by protesting Luton players as he made his way over to Andy Carroll. Robinson, to the horror of the home fans produced a second yellow and then a red card and Carroll was on his way back to the changing rooms. The referee’s assistant had spotted Carroll had deflected the ball past Horvath with his hand.

Down to ten men with over half an hour remaining, Reading faced the daunting prospect of hanging on to a slender lead against team that had already dominated possession for most of the game. Quite test for the team but also for a new manager in charge for only his second game. Once again credit to Noel Hunt for keeping his head, as he waited for his counterpart Rob Edwards to show his hand. The Luton manager made a triple substitution on seventy minutes to adjust his tactics to take full advantage of the extra man. Hunt immediately responded sensibly refreshing his midfield, preplacing Azeez and Fornah two youngsters he knew well. His faith in Abrefa and Camara paid off and will have no doubt boosted their confidence to be trusted in such an important game at such a crucial stage. I have to say boosting confidence was not a strength of Paul Ince, which I feel in part is the reason for the current predicament.

Surely Reading couldn’t withstand the persistent onslaught for over thirty minutes could they? Well they didn’t, but they did offer stubborn resistance. Luton equalised with ten minutes of normal time remaining, Morris bundling the ball over the line after Lumley failed, under pressure, to deal with a hopeful ball into the box. It would be unfair to criticise Lumley who was again in outstanding form, particularly in dealing with high balls into the box. If he does have a weakness it could possibly be communication with his defence. Just for change he received a yellow card for dissent instead off time-wasting.

Hunt immediately reacted by replacing Joao, not renowned for his work rate, with the youthful energy of Ehibhatiomhan. With Camara pushing forward down the left Reading looked to engage the Luton defence to relieve the incessant pressure on the Reading defence. Again tactically it worked and Reading held on for another sixteen minutes to give Reading a precious point and a glimmer of hope of avoiding the drop. It was a tribute to Reading’s rearguard action that a frustrated Luton began to concede free-kicks as they desperately searched for a winning goal.

A recurring, theme particularly in recent games, has been the way referee’s are very quick to show yellow cards to Reading players. I am wary of statistics generally but last night Luton conceded eleven free-kicks and received two yellow cards while Reading conceded ten but received five yellow cards. There were examples of Luton players being only punished with the award of free kick for which for which Reading players were carded. I just hope we get a strong referee if Reading need a point or three from the last game of the season to Huddersfield manged by Neil Warnock.

John Wells

League Position — 2022/2023

Post-Match Fans' Opinion

  • JM John Madejski's Wallet 19 Apr 2023 · 10:31pm

    Bit gutted by that. Really hoped we'd hold on and get out of relegation Luton were decent but I was quite happy with the style of football we were trying to play. If only we shifted Ince on a few weeks ago Azeez really frustrated me again. Lots of attacking pace, but just doesn't pass early enough. Two absolutely banging corners though And what to say about Carroll.....stupid yellow in 1st half chasing his own fukk up, awesome header, then ridiculous handball. Fukker Fair play for holding on and trusting the youngsters though

  • MI Millsy 19 Apr 2023 · 10:34pm

    Missed the game. Read the match thread. Good result. Ratings please someone.

  • HO Hound 19 Apr 2023 · 10:35pm

    Yeah hard to be too annoyed with Carroll but that act of stupidity cost us the game Weird to come home thinking that was a missed opportunity when we get a point after playing with 10 for half an hour against the 3rd place team - but that’s how I feel They were so there for the taking at the start of the second half - we were all over them for 10 mins

  • ST stealthpapes 19 Apr 2023 · 10:44pm

    I'll take some time to get over all of that. Tense. First half was assured, I felt. Nothing too amazing but matched a playoff side. Silly fouls, even yellows, here and there. Great header for 1-0, ludicrous second yellow with 30 to play. I was broadly level (GU10) and it was very clear. When they scored, I thought that was it. They'd simply swamp us with crosses etc. Good point but ... maybe not enough ...

  • JM John Madejski's Wallet 19 Apr 2023 · 10:52pm

    Yeah I saw it hit a hand, but assumed it was a defender's at the time

  • SR Snowflake Royal 19 Apr 2023 · 10:52pm

    Missed the game. Read the match thread. Good result. Ratings please someone. Lumley - 7 I guess, I think a good save and some good commanding of his area but didn’t get enough on the cross for the goal and then had no idea where the ball went. Yiadom - 7 good solid Yiadom of old performance Holmes - 7 put in a lot of good work Sarr - 7 one of his better games for sure Guiness-Walker - 6 got quite a lot wrong today but defenddd fairly well Hendrick - 6 Mr average. Casadei - 6 some good some not great, lost it a bit too much Azeez - 6 great couple of balls in, but doesn’t look fit and lost it a lot. Fornah - 5 I like him and the way…

  • MA Maguire 19 Apr 2023 · 11:23pm

    Thought we were distinctly second best in the first half after the opening 15mins, properly clinging on for half-time. Poor at keeping the ball and a goal looked inevitable (great block by Sarr). Much better start to the second half, a goal, then a dumb sending off. It was so obviously handball I didn't even celebrate the goal, but wonder how the ref came to his decision as he definitely awarded the goal and the linesman didn't seem to flag (?). Reading defended pretty manfully after that and, whilst the equaliser was a shame, it wasn't undeserved overall. Decent point but we'll need to offer more if we want to stay up.

  • JM John Madejski's Wallet 19 Apr 2023 · 11:29pm

    Thought we were distinctly second best in the first half after the opening 15mins, properly clinging on for half-time. Poor at keeping the ball and a goal looked inevitable (great block by Loum). Much better start to the second half, a goal, then a dumb sending off. It was so obviously handball I didn't even celebrate the goal, but wonder how the ref came to his decision as he definitely awarded the goal and the linesman didn't seem to flag (?). Reading defended pretty manfully after that and, whilst the equaliser was a shame, it wasn't undeserved overall. Decent point but we'll need to offer more if we want to stay up. Yeah I was…

Read all the discussion

This Championship game took place 1173 days ago in the 2022/2023 season.