The curse of ‘The Manager of the Month’ is the footballing equivalent of discovering Tutankhamun’s tomb. No sooner had McDermott won that poisoned chalice of an accolade for our upsurge in fortunes during January, the next fixture was absolutely bound to end in defeat. And although no-one would ever accuse our manager of getting too big for his boots, clearly something affected his head at Stoke as a couple of puzzling tactical changes went some way towards the impressive run of late being curtailed in the face of some naive defending from a Reading side who would argue they deserved better from the game.

The now familiar 4-5-1 line up saw one change from the excellent performance which dispatched Sunderland the previous weekend. Garath McCleary, patchy though his form wearing the hoops has been, will consider himself unfortunate to be dropped for Nick Blackman who made his full debut at the Britannia Stadium. It was a puzzling decision, perhaps McDermott wanted to make the most of Blackman’s extra height against the Stoke aerial bombardment but in real terms Blackman struggled to make any sort of creative impact on the Reading left and his debut can only be remembered as a failure. Despite the change, Reading started brightly enough but it was Stoke with the first opportunity; a corner flashed across the Reading box. It took the home side more than half an hour of a poor first half to work Federici; firstly Shawcross’s inelegant slice towards goal from a corner was shoved over the bar from Federici and he followed that up before half time with an impressive stop after the otherwise utterly ineffectual Crouch had been allowed time to tee-up a half volley. This second chance came as a result of sloppy defending from Harte who allowed Kightly in. It was a poor afternoon for Harte who looked every day of his 35 years in being given a good chasing by the pacy Stoke wingers and unfortunately his set pieces on the day were generally abysmal.

Reading created little in terms of quality chances in that opening period and did not test Begovic enough all afternoon, but the shape was good and Akpan was pulling strings in midfield to give our wide men plenty of the ball. Reading were well in the game and looking comfortable until halfway through the second half where Walters was allowed to spin in the area and his crashing effort went behind for a corner off Mariappa’s ankle. Whelan swept a deep corner into the far post and with Reading napping the outstanding player on the park Robert Huth climbed high above Kelly to crash a header home off the underside of the bar. Conceding goals as a result of a corner has become an unwelcome and regular occurrence in our season and this is a desperately poor way of conceding a goal when you consider the wealth of attacking riches most if not all of our opponents in the Premier League posses these days. When you manage to prevent a side from scoring from open play but then concede from a set piece then you may just as well not bother turning up. Reading certainly didn’t bother turning up for this corner and we were behind at a venue which has seen the visiting side triumph only once this season.

Prior to the opener goal, Stoke were able to bring on some attacking quality in Kenwyne Jones and Cameron Jerome. At one down, McDermott introduced the willing-if-not-always-able Noel Hunt, and therein lies the crux of our struggle when a midtable sides options look infinitely more impressive than ours. Hunt replaced Pogrebnyak, a curious move when chasing a goal given our direct style of play. With ALF having been introduced 10 minutes or so earlier, we now had two sub-six footers up against a giant Stoke backline led by the unsubtle Huth. The substitution compounded a frustrating afternoon for Pog as his final touch of the ball was to allow a Kebe pass from a 3-on-1 counter attack to roll past him to an impossible angle when McCleary was better placed. It was rather brain-dead football from Kebe and ultimately cost us a point as with Stoke’s next attack a familiar long ball was dealt with sloppily by Mariappa who headed the ball up into the air where it was collected by Jerome, who turned Pearce and smashed a fine strike past Federici who needn’t have bothered moving. A superb finish – who in the Reading team would you back to score a goal like that? – but given Stoke are famed for a successfully direct approach it was astonishing poor and naive play from us to allow the half chance.

Mariappa himself summed up the never-say-die attitude so familiar under McDermott which has been rediscovered in the last month by reacting first to a Hart corner which – for once, on this particular day – was on the money and crashing a near post header through Begovic just when we looked to be out of the game. Stoke had failed to win in six outings prior to this game and their nerves were evident as Reading dominated those closing stages looking for a familiar late significant goal. There were promptings and half-openings but Stoke were not to be caught short as they were for our own set-piece goal and ultimately our best opportunity seem to come in injury when ALF went down in the penalty box as if he’d been shot by a sniper. Time froze for a second, referee Oliver looked disinterested and ALF threw his hands up into the air. Moments later it was full time and as McDermott stormed off face like thunder via saluting the travelling support you wondered whether we’d been done an injustice. On seeing the replay, there was no such miscarriage and ALF had done himself no favours in his theatrics despite McDermott’s ludicrous post match protestations.

This was a missed opportunity to take a point from an out-of-form side who are admittedly strong on their own patch. If you want to get a result at Stoke you need to deal with set pieces and their long diagonal balls. For their two goals we failed in doing that, which should be more of a disappointment to McDermott than some spurious penalty claim. With the next four home games against sides around us in the table, these fixtures will take on monumental importance if we cannot improve on our meagre tally of five league points away from home by gifting our opposition goals with elementary errors as we did at the Britannia.
Neil Maskell

Stoke were always going to be man enough to crush our renaissance, and so it proved. Mariappa and Akpan both had decent games and looked quite comfortable. Kebe and McAnuff seemed a bit frightened of them and were ineffective, mind you, Wilikinson looks like a thug who nobody would really fancy playing against. First half wasn't very entertaining with few chances at either end. Stoke came out and turned the screw in the second half and it was no surprise they took the lead with us offering little going forward. Typical Stoke headed goal from Huth, and Jerome was just too hot for Pearce for their second.

Can't blame Pog as he had little to feed off and was unlikely to get any change out of their centre backs. Legs was brave to go into that challenge with Whelan who had some intent with his studs raised. Pulled an unlikely goal back but couldn't see an equaliser coming tbh, Alf was looking for a pen and the ref called it right. Wouldn't want to be a Stoke ST holder, crap football and all that money just to watch a bloke take a throw in.
Royalclapper

Always dissapointing to lose, whoever the opposition, but not too down about it. I would have bitten your hand off 6 weeks ago to be in this position as back then there was no light at the end of the tunnel.

With regards to the game, then I think the best team won. They had the better chances and more of the possesion so there can be no complaints from our side. Ultimately Stoke won the physical battle from thew outset and apart from pockets of time when we played it around nicely, we never really looked that threatening from open play. At times we did look like a Premiership side and there were positives to take from it. BM´s gamble of playing Blackman didn´t really come off IMO and maybe we missed Gurthie a little. Stoke are an experiecned Prem team and maybe we needed that extra bit of top flight experience, but hindseight..wonderful thing.... etc...The subsititutions certainly made a difference to Stoke and shows the strengh if depth we will need next season if we stay up and want to avoid another relegation dogfight. Nevermind the superbly taken goal that any Striker would have been proud of, I personally thought Cameron Jerome was excellent allround when he came on and made a noticeable difference to Stoke.

What could be crucial is the goal we got at the end. Mentally could help us as we were not drubbed and with a feeling of inustice over the penalty inccident, could mean we come up against Wigan with something to prove. With regards to the Penalty, my initial thoughts were no and I think ALF appeared to be looking for the pen too much to actually get awarded it.

Now it is Wigan at our place, and anything other than 3 points could be a disaster. Southampton´s performance today was impressive to say the least and they may start pulling away from the dog fight. I think todays defeat for QPR is pretty much ´Game Over´for them now so it could be shaping up for 2 from Villa, us and Wigan to complete the 3 relegations places. Whatever happens I am sure it will go down to the last game of the season. My bum is already squeaking.
Big Ern